Why "Are These Two Signs Compatible?" Is the Wrong Question
The question comes up constantly: are Scorpio and Aquarius compatible? Are Aries and Cancer a good match? The impulse is understandable, but the framing skips most of the information that actually matters. Two people aren't their sun signs alone. They're a full twelve-planet, twelve-house chart, and most of the dynamics in a relationship are shaped by factors that never appear in a sun-sign compatibility grid.
Sun sign pairings describe a rough energetic overlap — fixed water meets fixed air, cardinal fire meets cardinal water — but they say very little about how two specific people will actually experience each other. For that, you need to look at both charts together.
What Synastry Actually Examines
Synastry is the technical term for comparing two birth charts by overlaying them. What astrologers examine isn't primarily which signs appear in each chart, but the angular relationships — called aspects — that form between planets across the two charts.
Stephen Arroyo, in Relationships and Life Cycles (1979), frames synastry as an examination of how two people's developmental cycles intersect, not simply whether their personalities complement each other. It's a more honest framing: relationships aren't static compatibility tests. They're ongoing interactions between two people who are both changing.
Some of the most significant synastry connections to look at:
Venus-Mars contacts between charts often indicate attraction and relational chemistry. When one person's Venus closely aspects another's Mars, there's frequently a pull-and-pursue dynamic that can be exciting early on but requires awareness as the relationship matures.
Moon-Moon connections reveal emotional attunement — or the lack of it. When two moons are in compatible elements, emotional communication often feels natural. When they're in challenging aspect, both people may feel chronically misunderstood even when they're trying to connect.
Saturn contacts are among the most consequential in long-term relationships. Liz Greene, in Relating: An Astrological Guide to Living with Others (1977), writes at length about how Saturn connections can create a sense of obligation or karmic weight — sometimes experienced as support and structure, sometimes as restriction. Whether that weight becomes productive or burdensome depends largely on how the relationship handles accountability.
Mercury connections matter significantly in friendships and working relationships, where communication style compatibility shapes the texture of every interaction. Two people whose Mercury signs are in trine often feel like they speak the same language. Square or opposition aspects don't make communication impossible — they just mean more conscious translation is usually required.
A Comparison Table: Synastry Contacts and What They Tend to Indicate
| Synastry Contact | Relationship Domain | Common Experience |
|---|---|---|
| Venus conjunct Mars | Romance, attraction | Strong pull, dynamic energy, worth watching for pursuit patterns |
| Moon trine Moon | Emotional | Natural ease, instinctive understanding |
| Moon square Moon | Emotional | Recurring misattunement, requires deliberate effort |
| Saturn conjunct Sun | Structure, long-term | Serious commitment, can feel supportive or heavy |
| Mercury sextile Mercury | Communication | Easy exchange, ideas travel well between them |
| Jupiter conjunct Venus | Enjoyment, growth | Expansive pleasure, shared enthusiasm |
| Pluto square Sun | Power, transformation | Intensity, potential for deep change — or destabilization |
No single contact tells the whole story. Synastry is cumulative: a chart with five harmonious contacts and one difficult Pluto square reads differently than a chart where the Pluto square is the only major connection.
Compatibility in Practice: Beyond Romance
Romantic compatibility gets most of the attention, but relationship astrology is just as useful for understanding other kinds of bonds. The Aries sun sign and Taurus sun sign blog posts both include notes on how those energies tend to interact in different relationship contexts — romantic, platonic, and professional.
In a working relationship, Saturn and Mercury contacts often matter more than Venus or Mars. A colleague whose Saturn falls on your Mercury might feel like a demanding editor who slows everything down — or like the person who catches the errors that would have cost you later. Context and communication determine which version of that dynamic plays out.
Friendship synastry often hinges on moon and Jupiter contacts — shared emotional wavelength and a sense of mutual enjoyment and expansion. Friendships with strong Saturn connections can be deeply loyal but sometimes feel obligatory rather than chosen.
What Compatibility Readings Are Not
Compatibility readings don't predict whether a relationship will succeed or fail. Two charts can look extraordinarily compatible on paper and still struggle if neither person is willing to address their own patterns. Two charts with significant tension can produce a relationship with remarkable depth and creativity if both people are curious about what the tension is pointing to.
The more honest use of a compatibility reading is diagnostic rather than predictive. What patterns are most likely to surface? Where will the natural rhythms align, and where will both people need to compensate? What's the dynamic around decision-making, emotional expression, or handling conflict?
That kind of specificity is what makes relationship astrology genuinely useful — not as an endorsement or warning about a particular pairing, but as a vocabulary for patterns that are often already present but hard to name.
Faal generates the synastry reading from two sets of birth details and explains the key contacts in plain language. You can explore your own natal foundations in the birth chart feature before running the comparison, which often makes the synastry interpretation considerably clearer.
Frequently asked questions
Does zodiac compatibility determine whether a relationship will work?
No. Compatibility readings surface patterns and potential friction points worth noticing. They don't predict outcomes. A so-called difficult pairing can thrive with good communication, and a harmonious pairing can still run into real trouble.
What is synastry?
Synastry is the comparison of two people's birth charts overlaid on each other. Astrologers look at which planets in one chart form angles with planets in the other, and interpret what those connections tend to mean in practice.
Can I check compatibility with a friend or colleague, not just a romantic partner?
Yes. Faal's compatibility feature works for any two people. Friendship and professional relationships have their own astrological dynamics — Mercury and Saturn contacts matter quite differently in a work context than Venus and Mars contacts do.
Do I need both people's birth times for a compatibility reading?
Exact birth times produce the most complete synastry reading. Without them, Faal can still compare sun, moon, Venus, Mars, and other planetary signs — but rising sign overlays and house connections won't be available.
Is sun sign compatibility enough?
Sun sign compatibility is a starting point, but it's a limited one. Faal goes deeper by comparing moon signs, Venus and Mars placements, and the major angular relationships between charts — which is where the most revealing dynamics often show up.
Get Faal today
Free on iOS and Android. Your first reading is on us.

